I suppose because of Guy Ritchie's divergent style, the Amazon Prime, eight-episode miniseries, Young Sherlock, which the director devised with writers/co-creators Peter Harness and Matthew Parkhill, should be considered a prequel to his retailored, Robert Downey Jr./Jude Law Holmes/Watson set. However, some say it should be taken at no more than face value. Maybe. Maybe not. It doesn't matter much. It all evens out in the crafty, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wash.
For me, the series proved a curious run of fun, even as its two plots bumpered off each other in the manner of many Star Trek: The Next Generation episodes, or as in Harold Becker's crime melodrama, Malice, though unlike the latter, the concepts did come together by the culmination. All the same, after Young Sherlock's investigative dust clears, it's all about family, friendship and dangerous deception.
To fulfill the ingredients, we have Hero Fiennes Tiffin as the nineteen-year-old Holmes; Max Irons as his mindful, older brother, Mycroft; Natascha McElhone as his distraught mother, Cordelia; Joseph Fiennes as his shifty father, Silas; Colin Firth as the shady Bucephalus Hodge; Holly Cattle as the unassuming yet surprising Edie/Beatrice; Zine Tseng as the principled Princess Gulun Shou'an; Iris Li as the deflecting Mei Li Liu, and last but not least (drumroll, please!), Donal Finn as Holmes' mischievous rival, James Moriarty.
The intertwining (Oxford-flanking and far beyond) plots concern the securing of ancient, Asian scrolls that hold world-shaking consequences and the other deals with Holmes' mother, who was committed to a mental institution after his wee sister perished. The big question is, did his dear sister truly die or is she (hint hint) hiding in plain sight?
The quest for the scrolls is action-oriented, at times staged like a chapter play (i.e. an Indiana Jones adventure) or maybe it's more in line with Barry Levinson's Young Sherlock Holmes, which does hold similar high-flying setups. The family-based track, on the other hand, brews pure mystery, with a subtle build that never quite culminates in horror, but still churns the chills. There's also a pulpy, 007/Green Hornet "nerve gas" at the heart of it all, which ties the halves in a nice, toxic bow.
I'm uncertain which of the series' melodramas I prefer. They're both interesting and in all honesty, could have distinguished two separate seasons. The juxtaposing still clicks, and that's all that matters, but the textures do tend to dart in extreme, opposite directions. For some, the contrast may feel more exasperating than complementary.
Even with its apparent, aesthetic clashes, Young Sherlock's characters hold absolute command, with the Holmes/Moriarty link being the most emphasized, placing the lads at consistent, amiable odds and adventurous peril. The idea of these noted foes as friends (and ones whose personalities click and clack in such a rambunctious way) is quite novel, considering where they're headed.
Regardless of Holmes and Moriarty's fated breakup (a heavy hint of which surfaces in the final moments of the season finale), the series' mirthful partnership is worth the visit, and lots more can be culled from the concept. I wonder what might be bubbling for Season 2, and if another twofold approach is planned. With the thematic tactic now established, it might as well continue. If, indeed, used, the duplicity will all come down to how well it blends, and I'm betting (at least as far as my disposition goes) the formula reinstates the same mercurial yet opulent intrigue.