Showing posts with label Dune: Prophesy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dune: Prophesy. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 1, 2025

I SAW DUNE PROPHESY (AN IMPRESSION)

I feared Dune: Prophesy might get too bogged down in political ramifications, in the way of SyFy's complex Krypton, and damn it, it did. Political anchoring needn't be a cloudy hinderance, if such draws one in, and Dune: Prophesy had the advantage of weaving spirituality into its power-and-control theme, but when push came to shove, it was at best an exercise in chatter. 

I'll admit, it wasn't too hard for me to latch on to the virile aspects of the miniseries, watching as I did through the eyes and actions of Mark Strong's Emperor Javicco Corrino and Travis Fimmel's Desmond Hart, and for what it's worth, Emily Watson's Valya Harkonnen felt quite right in her regal status (channeling, for all intent, Judi Dench), but I wanted desperation and rage to permeate through all the dissertation. I wanted a friggin, full-blown, extraterrestrial, Game of Thrones-meets-Black Narcissus. I wanted the prequel to brew and bubble over in its desperate, Sisterhood prophesy of a messiah's rise, or at least something like that. I mean, for crying out loud, this thing flows like Exorcist II: The Heretic on valium, and though I realize such an approach might attract a rebellious few, I still maintain that even the most pensive sojourns require thundery claps, and by that I mean, more than just a sex scene, a sand-worm cameo, a come-and-go explosion ... a Last Jedi-influenced melee. To worsen matters, Prophesy follows such things with lengthy regurgitations of whispery nonchalance. 

To toss further dust on the dying fire, the times when Prophesy proved beautiful to behold (evading, oddly enough, substantial, Lawrence of Arabia stretches for landscapes that invoke The Ewok Adventures, Lord of the Rings, Zardoz and Excalibur), there would come moments when even the travelogue backdrops felt like watching paint dry. (This is one of the things I find irksome about the Harry Potter franchise, where sorcery, no matter how elevated, feels flat, especially when the glitz is wiped away to reveal a Hitler Jugend agenda.) 

Now, I'm happy to say that I didn't detect anything ideologically amiss (i.e. too radical) in Prophesy, but even so, I wanted it to move me in the most positive and profound way. I don't see the point of HBO Max extending it, anymore than I see the network's necessity to rehash all that propagandist, anti-Semitic, Potter fluff. Please, nurture The Penguin instead, and from there, the subscription-viewing region will be all the better for it, not to mention Dune's theatrical continuation. In other words, we don't need a yawn-fest to blunt what's become a prosperous, big-screen perch.

Monday, November 18, 2024

DUNE: PROPHESY (A PREQUEL ASCENDS)

The HBO/Max, six-part prequel, Dune: Prophesy (derived from Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson's Sisterhood of Dune) has begun, with preordained regal house against regal house, and though it's too soon for me to judge the conflict on the whole, I can still offer my forefront acknowledgments and views.

The first acknowledgment is the series' vast cast, which is worthy of Dune's erudite heritage: Emily Watson, Olivia Williams, Jodhi May, Sarah-Sofi Bossnina, Shalom Brune-Franklin, Aoife Hinds, Jade Anouka and among these talented ladies, Travis (Vikings/Warcraft) Fimmel and Mark (The Penguin/Shazam!) Strong.  

The second acknowledgment is the opening's verbosity. With this said, heavy exposition (in this case, of an anti-machine, feminist movement that wishes to birth a JFK knockoff ... sort of, I think) isn't necessarily a bad thing. For example, Heretic is verbose, and because of it, its story is damn riveting. Prophesy's introduction, however, seems more like a university seminar, detailing a spiritual experience that, because of its immense weight, makes its mysticism secular. 

On this basis, I feel compelled to liken the new Dune to Syfy's Krypton: a lavish series, jammed with historic, DC details and motivating philosophies, but with little to have kicked it into high, pre-Kal El gear. 

I'm not saying for certain that this Dune prequel will suffer Krypton's short-lived, history-anchored fate. And Prophesy more than deserves a shot, and it may yet deliver the long-haul goods, even enough to get fans pumped for that next, theatrical chapter.

Then again, even if it should click by season's end, sometimes too good a thing can hinder what ensues. For example, some have said that Star Trek: The Next Generation blunted the anticipatory thunder of Star Trek V: The Final Frontier, and that Freddy's Nightmares had sucked the frightful surrealism well in advance of A Nightmare on Elm Street 5: The Dream Child. (I suppose, one could apply the same view to The Penguin, but that track holds a more independent structure to its platform: connected, yes, but still a clear-cut bridge all unto itself.)

We'll see if Prophesy causes friction or cohesion for Dune's filmed continuation. For now, I (along with other interested parties) will keep viewing, and when the time comes, reflect on the season's accumulation.