Director Emma Tammi's Five Nights at Freddy's 2 (aka FNaF2), based on the five-phase, video franchise, continues the 2023 original's animatronic madness with the soul-trapped, robot monsters returning (and new ones joining), emblemized by the lumbering Freddy Fazbear (voiced by Kellen Goff), though for this chapter's longer haul, led by Chica (voiced by Megan Fox) and the lanky harlequin, Marionette. By insidious default, this means that Matthew (Scream/Twin Peaks/Scooby-Doo) Lillard falls to a supporting, "spiritual" role as child murderer, William Afton, just to ensure the marginal creepiness is never just marginal. (Afton is significant, after all, for having planted his victims' youthful bodies, and consequently, their souls, inside their formidable shells.)
For this follow-up, the Freddy's Pizzeria franchise has been relegated to frivolous, urban legend, but Mike, played by Josh Hutcherson, and Vanessa (Afton's beleaguered daughter), played by Elizabeth Lail, know better. When Mike's sister, Abby, played by Piper Rubio, returns to her mischievous, nocturnal friends at their prototype hub, that's when things get dicey, leaving the couple to intervene before the garish characters make her a permanent part of their vengeful, doom patrol.
Based on this summary, one might presume Freddy's 2 is more standard than not, and to some extent, one might be right (in other words, Freddy's 2 is no Bride of Frankenstein, Dawn of the Dead 1979 or Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn), but it needn't aspire to be more than it is, for its content succeeds in spurring a string of scares. (Perhaps, the weight of its sinister success stems from its Westworld 1973 setup, and even more than the first Freddy's, the sequel makes excellent use of its marauding menaces, enough that even an android Yul Brynner would bestow an approving nod.)
The cast is beneficial, too, in particular Hutcherson and Lail, who present enough identifiable stress to pull one in, which in turn gives the other personas (whether organic or synthetic) a better means to bounce off them. Lillard stands out, as well, offering sporadic instigation: an effective, ethereal contrast to the corporeal guises that comprise the automaton army. (Quirky kudos also go to Wayne Knight as a cantankerous, robotics teacher and Freddy Carter as a Renfield-ish watchman with a profound secret.)
Tammi's direction doesn't miss a beat, either, as she makes this one more vehement than the first. Scott Cawthon's script deserves comparable credit, with the sequel's pacing moving seamlessly from his prior effort, though enabled by heightened peril and a path for more. (Freddy's 3 is as good as sold, as long as the current chapter's box-office receipts justify it.)
It would have been preferable, I suppose, if Freddy's 2 had been released around Halloween, but then the Christmas-movie season has never been devoid of horror pictures. Freddy's 2 holds an honorable place in that offbeat, Yuletide tradition, being creepy yet joyful in its twisted-toy premise to satisfy those wanting a little, killer edge this holiday season.